Permanent Establishment · Reasoning Engine

Complete, source-referenced PE analysis in minutes — not days.

A purpose-built reasoning engine for Permanent Establishment risks. We started with the legal reasoning — the AI only executes it.

MVP end of May 2026. Pilot partnerships open in June. Commercial launch Q4 2026. A limited number of pilot slots remain.

Pilot conversations under way with Benelux advisory firms and Fortune 500 in-house tax teams. Named references will be added as each pilot confirms public attribution.

The dilemma

Today's PE work forces an uncomfortable choice.

Cross-border activity, remote work and digital business models keep producing new taxable footprints. Tax teams are forced to choose between two flawed options — neither of which scales.

Option A · slow

Bespoke advice for every question.

Days or weeks of senior hours per question. Deep analysis but margin-thin for the firm, prohibitively expensive for the client, impossible to scale across a portfolio.

Option B · risky

Quick & dirty email confirmation.

A one-line answer with no source trail and no defensibility. The exposure does not disappear — it surfaces years later, in a tax audit, with penalties and profit-attribution adjustments attached.

exPErtus

eliminates that dilemma.

Days of legal analysis. Minutes of execution. Every memo grounded in OECD Commentary, doctrine, treaty text and case law — with sequential footnotes a partner, a tax director or an inspector can verify.

Why this is structurally hard

PE is the most fact-driven, locally interpreted area in international tax.

Three structural realities make PE work uniquely difficult — and uniquely poorly served by both traditional advisory and broad AI tools.

100+

The reasoning

Hundreds of sources per case.

Every PE outcome turns on fact patterns mapped across treaty text, OECD Commentary, doctrine, case law and country-specific guidance. No two cases reach the conclusion via the same path — until the reasoning itself is encoded.

Years

The exposure

PE issues crystallize years after the fact.

Operational decisions taken today surface in tax audits years later — when commercial models have moved on and exposures are no longer reversible. By the time the issue is visible, the cost is already real.

~55%

The shortcut that doesn't work

Broad AI saves time, not risk.

General-purpose models save 50–60% of consultant time, but produce inconsistent reasoning, invented citations and no audit trail. They look credible. They are not defensible. The heavy lifting — and the liability — stays with you.

How exPErtus works

Decision-engine-first.

We did not start with a large language model and bolt legal context onto it. We started with the legal reasoning itself — and only then added an AI execution layer on top.

1

The decision tree.

Authored by senior PE practitioners and academics. Mirrors the analytical path an experienced specialist actually walks — step by step, condition by condition.

2

The interpretation layer.

Each node carries explicit instructions: how the condition is understood, which nuances matter, which fact patterns are decisive. The engine never improvises interpretation.

3

The source mapping.

Every node points to specific sources — treaty articles, OECD Commentary, doctrine, case law, rulings. Precise references for a precise legal question.

4

The execution.

A controlled language model walks the predefined path, applies the mapped sources, and articulates the conclusion in clean professional output. The same answer, every time.

Reasoning structure — more than 700 decision “nodes”

Does the Treaty adhere to the post-2017 Agency PE definition? Interpretative layer + 5 sources
no
Does the agent have formal authority to sign contracts on behalf of Company X? Interpretative layer + 20 sources
yes
Is the agent acting in the name of the Company? Interpretative layer + 25 sources
yes
Is it specifically mentioned in the Agency PE Article that purchasing activities are excluded? Interpretative layer + 10 sources
evaluating…
Architecture

Two layers. By design.

The legal reasoning sits in one tier. The AI sits in another. That separation is what makes the output dependable.

Tier 01 · proprietary

The reasoning framework.

Decision structure, interpretive layer, source mapping. Authored and maintained by senior PE specialists. The legal reasoning lives here.

Tier 02 · controlled LLM

The execution layer.

A controlled LLM articulates the conclusion in clean professional language. It cannot invent legal interpretation — only execute one.

Two layers. One guarantee: the engine cannot invent answers.

The deliverable

A legal memorandum in the format your clients, partners and auditors expect.

Every exPErtus analysis produces a structured legal memorandum — sequential footnotes, risk classification, do's and don'ts, recommended next steps. The same shape a senior advisor would hand you, at a fraction of the cost.

Anatomy of every memo

  1. 01IntroductionScope, legal basis, standard advisory disclaimer.
  2. 02Our understanding of the factsA clean restatement of the intake before analysis begins.
  3. 03Fiscal queryThe precise legal questions — typically one or more PE types under a specific treaty.
  4. 04Theoretical frameworkApplicable legal framework, with treaty-specific PE scoping.
  5. 05Application to the factsCondition-by-condition analysis. Every conclusion anchored to a source reference.
  6. 06ConclusionRisk classification with do's and don'ts and recommended next steps.
One click · multiple formats

From structured memo to the document your context actually needs.

Core Full legal memorandum Sections 01–06 · fully footnoted
Output · A High-level e-mail advice Client-ready summary in plain language.
Output · B Ruling request Formal submission to the tax authority.
Output · C Defence file Audit-ready argumentation, source-referenced.
PE types covered

From home offices to offshore installations — the full PE landscape.

exPErtus covers the Permanent Establishment concepts that dominate international tax practice, with dedicated reasoning paths for each PE archetype.

Fixed Place of Business PE.All archetypes such as home offices, client premises, warehouses, servers, pipelines, moving objects, stock of goods, etc.
Agency PE.Hereby distinguishing old and new definitions.
Construction PE.Both onshore and offshore sites.
Service PE.Where the specific treaty covers this type of PE.
MLI considerations.Applicability of anti-fragmentation, Principal Purpose Test, etc.
Country-specific interpretation.Domestic case law, local tax-authority positions and jurisdiction-specific guidance, treaty by treaty.
Why exPErtus

Purpose-built — where horizontal tools fall short.

Horizontal AI tools, tax governance platforms and internal AI initiatives each solve a slice of the problem. None of them deliver complete, source-referenced PE analysis end-to-end.

 
Horizontal tools
exPErtus
LLM-based AI tools
Frontier LLM + retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) over a legal corpus. The LLM decides what to retrieve and how to synthesize, per query. Outputs vary between runs, contain errors and are rarely fully complete; sources are too often hallucinated.
Predefined reasoning path, authored by senior PE specialists. Each node pre-mapped to its sources. The LLM only executes — it never decides what to retrieve, interpret or cite. Deterministic, bounded, fully audit-traceable.
TaxTech & governance platforms
Flag risks and track obligations. Useful for compliance — but stop short of in-depth legal analysis.
Full legal analysis, not just a risk flag. The memo is the output.
Firm-internal AI initiatives
Broad, horizontal research accelerators built for general use. They speed up research — but the PE reasoning, source mapping and final interpretation still sit with the user.
Deep, niche-specific reasoning engine — designed as shared infrastructure for the international tax profession.
Team

Decades of PE expertise, encoded.

exPErtus is built by a combination of senior international tax practice, legal academia, and deep-tech delivery experience — a lockstep expertise combination that is rare in the market.

HB

Hovik Begian

CEO · Co-founder

15 years of international tax experience with large (a.o. Big 4) consulting firms. Leads commercial, client relationships, and go-to-market.

TW

Tim Wustenberghs

Legal & Academic Lead · Co-founder

30 years of PE expertise. Tax Partner and Professor at the University of Antwerp. Architect of the proprietary reasoning framework.

TB

Toon Bogaerts

CTO · Co-founder

Second-time founder with a background as a professional researcher in AI. Previously co-founded and successfully sold a service-based AI firm. Leads end-to-end technical vision and delivery.

Thinking

Notes on the craft of PE analysis.

Work from the team on how the reasoning engine is built, how source material maps onto practice, and where the PE discipline is heading. We'll post here as we go.

Series · Reasoning architecture

Why a decision framework beats a clever prompt.

Professional PE work needs the same answer every time, with every step traceable to a source. We walk through why a structured reasoning layer — not a bigger prompt — is what turns AI output into something a partner, an in-house tax director or an auditor can actually rely on.

White paper · coming soon
Series · Legal articles

Reading the 2025 Commentary update against traditional home office analysis.

The 2025 OECD Commentary update sharpens the tests for home office PE — "at the disposal", business connection, the role of employer instruction. We compare the new framing with how home office cases have historically been analysed, and unpack what genuinely changes for cross-border employers today.

White paper · coming soon
Series · Field notes

Germany's position on home office PE exposure anno 2026.

A close read of the BMF draft guidance of 13 February 2025 and the positions German tax authorities are taking in practice — what they consider a home office PE, where they push back, and what this means for Belgian, Dutch and other EU employers with staff working from Germany.

White paper · coming soon
Trust & compliance

Built for the standards the tax profession operates under.

Designed from the ground up for GDPR and the EU AI Act. Your data stays in the EU, under controlled access, and is never used to train models.

EU-hosted infrastructure · assessment data and training data strictly separated · sequential footnotes on every output.

FAQ

Common questions from advisors and in-house teams.

What is a Permanent Establishment (PE), and why does it matter?

A PE is the international-tax concept that defines when a cross-border company creates a taxable presence in another country. Once a PE exists, the consequences are real: corporate tax registration, profit attribution, payroll obligations and VAT implications — often surfacing years later in a tax audit, when corrective action is no longer possible. PE analysis is inherently fact-driven, treaty-specific and locally interpreted, which is exactly why it absorbs so much senior advisory time. See the full explainer with worked example →

How is exPErtus different from ChatGPT, Claude and other LLM-based tax tools?

They all share an architecture that exPErtus does not. ChatGPT and Claude generate text from probabilistic patterns. Specialised legal-AI platforms and tax-specific tools sit on top of a frontier LLM with retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) over a curated legal corpus — the LLM decides per query what to retrieve and how to synthesize it. That works for fast research, but two structural problems remain for high-stakes PE work: the reasoning path varies between runs, outputs contain errors and are rarely fully complete, and sources are too often hallucinated. See the full architectural comparison →

exPErtus inverts the architecture. The reasoning path for every PE question is predefined in a proprietary decision framework, authored by senior PE specialists, with each node pre-mapped to its authoritative sources. The LLM only executes that path — it never decides what to retrieve, interpret or cite. The result: deterministic reasoning, bounded sources, and a complete audit trail.

What's in the deliverable?

A structured legal memorandum: introduction and scope, our understanding of the facts, the fiscal query, the applicable legal framework, condition-by-condition application to the facts, and a conclusion with risk classification, do's and don'ts and recommended next steps. Every reference is footnoted to the specific OECD Commentary paragraph, treaty article, doctrine or case law it relies on. The same memo can be re-rendered as a high-level email advice, a ruling request or a defence file.

How does exPErtus prevent hallucinations?

By architecture, not by guardrails. Generic AI is well-known for fabricating citations — Mata v. Avianca set the precedent (a New York lawyer was sanctioned for filing a brief with non-existent cases generated by ChatGPT). Even purpose-built legal RAG tools still hallucinate 17–33% of the time according to Magesh et al. (2025), Journal of Empirical Legal Studies, because the LLM still chooses what to retrieve and synthesize per query. exPErtus removes that risk at the source: every citation in our output is predefined at the decision node where it is used. The LLM cannot discover, invent, or fabricate sources — they are baked in. If a source appears in a memo, it exists in the framework, has been verified by senior PE specialists, and applies to that specific legal question.

How does exPErtus fit into existing workflows?

Two interaction modes. A structured chat interface mirrors how advisors already gather facts: it identifies what's needed, asks targeted questions, and produces the analysis. Or an email-based mode: the advisor forwards a client email to exPErtus, the platform extracts facts and sends targeted follow-ups to the client (on the advisor's behalf), and delivers the final memo to the advisor for review and approval before it reaches the client. The advisor stays in control throughout — only the speed and consistency change.

Does exPErtus replace tax advisors?

No. It transforms what they can do. For advisory firms, exPErtus dramatically reduces lead time and cost per analysis — freeing senior hours for higher-value work like planning, structuring, audit defence and client relationships. The trusted advisor relationship is preserved; the engine simply makes the work faster, more consistent and more profitable.

Can users rely on the output for audit defence?

Yes. Every output follows orthodox PE reasoning methodology and carries a complete audit trail. Each conclusion is traceable to the specific treaty provision, OECD Commentary paragraph, case law or doctrine that supports it. The output is suitable for internal decision-making, sharing with external advisors and defending positions during a tax audit.

What happens when tax treaties or legislation change?

The reasoning engine is modular and source-mapped, so legal changes are integrated through a structured maintenance process overseen by our expert team. exPErtus has a structural collaboration with a world's leading independent provider of cross-border tax expertise. Treaty changes, OECD Commentary updates, relevant case law and legislative developments are systematically channelled and pre-processed — the engine always operates on the most current authoritative sources.

How is client data protected?

Data is processed in a controlled, EU-hosted environment. Client inputs are never used to train models — training data and assessment data are strictly separated. exPErtus is designed from the ground up for GDPR (data minimisation, purpose limitation, storage limitation) and aligned with the EU AI Act's transparency and human-in-the-loop requirements. ISO 27001 certification is in progress.

When can we get access?

The MVP is ready end of May 2026. A limited number of pilot slots open in June 2026. Commercial launch is Q4 2026. Join the waitlist below to be contacted about a pilot or early-access engagement.

See the full FAQ →

Join the waitlist

Be among the first to see exPErtus in action.

We're opening a limited number of pilot slots ahead of commercial launch. Email us to start the conversation — no mass mailings, no drip campaigns.

We'll only use your email to contact you about exPErtus. See our privacy notice.